Skip to content

Are Natural Disasters Actually GOOD For The Economy?

The longstanding dispute among economists over the impact of natural disasters on economic growth is as compelling as it is eye-opening. It may appear to be obvious to anyone you may ask that the immediate impact of a natural disaster could not have any sort of economic benefit for the community that was impacted. In fact, most economists would agree with this. The main divide in the debate comes down to differences towards the beliefs oh what happens after the immediate effects. Some economists argue that the positive economic effects of a natural disaster outweigh the negative effects in the long-term. This paper will identify the differences of short-term and long-term effects in regard to national disasters. explore in depth the reasoning behind both of these schools of thought will be explored in depth as well as an analysis on the difference between first-world and third-world countries and whether or not these same economic theories would apply.

There is little
disagreement on the immediate effects a natural disaster has on the economy of
a given community. Immediate, or short-term in this instance would be defined
as a period from when the disaster is occurring to roughly 36 months after the
incident. According to the Public Entity Risk Institute, small businesses and
Not-for-Profits are known to experience phenomenal loss. “Every year, large
numbers of small businesses and not-for-profit organizations across the United
States suffer major losses as a direct consequence of earthquakes, severe
storms, and flooding. Small business and not-for-profit failures are
significant losses for communities of all sizes. When even one of them must
close, much is lost both to the individual and the community (Risk Institute).”
Unlike a big organization such as Walmart or McDonalds, destruction of one
these small businesses or organizations could end the livelihood of an entire
family, if not more. The report by the Risk Institute goes on to theorize the reasoning
behind this. “A business or not for-profit need not suffer damage in a natural
hazard event to find itself in peril following the event. One reason
manufacturing firms recover more quickly than many kinds of retail firms are
that their customer base tends to be geographically diverse (Risk Institute).” When
it comes to economic growth, it is clear that natural disasters in the short
term tend to put a halt on production in communities, specifically in regard to
smaller business that rely on members of the community it resides in.

Furthermore, it
does not even matter if a small businesses location is physically untouched by
the disaster itself, they will still experience short term negative effects. “Retail
and service organizations that serve a customer base that is geographically
concentrated suffer badly when the area is damaged or destroyed, even if the
firm itself receives no damage at all (Risk Institute).”  While at first thought it may seem strange to
think a business could be harshly effected by a tornado or flood that missed
the stores location. However when you put the buying power of the community
into consideration, It makes perfect sense that a business would struggle when
a community is diminished by a natural disaster. It is essentially a ripple
effect from a natural disaster in a communities economy, harm done by the
natural disaster in the second-degree in a sense. If one owned an electronics
store in a community that happened to experience a large hurricane there is a
high chance this business will suffer in the short term even if the store itself
incurs no physical damage from the storm itself. The damage done to the
community will bring down the buying power of the members in it as consumers
would be leaving the community or using their income and savings on essentials
such as housing repairs or medical bills. With less buying power in the average
community members hand, there is less capital circulating around the community.

As one would
expect, the effects on a communities economy are negative in the short term.
For one, a natural disaster could cause physical damage to a stores location or
merchandise. This would cause immediate loss and sometimes closure. Businesses
closing in a community can also close business near by that relied on them for
their production. Even if a small business were to avoid being physically
damaged by a natural disaster, economically the business would still take a
negative hit. Natural disasters bring down the buying power of the average
member of a community meaning less consumers to keep stores and business in
production.

While there seems
to be a lot of agreeance on short term effects of a natural disaster, there are
varying schools of thought when it comes to the long term. “Major natural
disasters can have severe negative short-run economic and budgetary impacts.
Disasters also appear to have adverse longer-term consequences for economic
growth, development and poverty reduction (Benson and Clay).” When it comes to
the effects of a natural disaster on a community in the long term, economists
are not in as much agreeance. There are many different theories with varying
conclusions.

                The
main argument that economists point to when compiling evidence to support a
theory that natural disasters benefit the economy is the notable rise in GDP.
While it is not incorrect to claim that there is a rise in GDP in wealthy
countries after a natural disaster, it is important to note that it is not
necessarily a measure of the strength of an economy (Noir). In fact, a rising
GDP in a wealthy country is to be expected after a natural disaster in the same
way it is expected when a country like the United States when it goes to war. When
there is production going on inside a countries border GDP will rise. This
applies to communities that are hit by natural disasters (Noir). When a
community has it’s infrastructure destroyed, it has no choice but to
reconstruct. This will be done whether it is from the community budget,
government funding from agencies, or donations. While there are certain
scenarios, like home repair, that could possibly create production organically
in the economy, a lot of the production is coming from money that is funneled
in. A lot of times this money is just government funding or money being used
from a community’s budget, which of course is derived from the tax payers. GDP
is essentially considered an inflated statistic in this school of thought.

On the topic of
GDP as evidence of natural disasters being beneficial for the economy there is
another point to remember, the rise in GDP does not take into account the cost
that the natural disaster inflicted on the community. GDP does not account for
this as it only shows the amount of domestic production. “Natural disasters can
affect long-term outcomes through a number of channels, including environmental
damage to agriculture, fishing, and forestry. The destruction of schools could
have a long-lasting negative impact on the stock of human capital;
reconstruction efforts could crowd out productive capital expenditure;
increased indebtedness could raise the rate of interest and reduce investment;
and a worsening of fiscal and external balances could trigger inflation and/or
financial crises (Rasmussen).” If a community took a hard economic hit on their
infrastructures that would take 20 years to repair, it may look like the
economy is on the rise when looking at GDP, but in reality they are making up
lost infrastructure.

The argument that
natural disasters are beneficial to a counties economy only extends to
countries that are wealthy. “Though richer nations do not experience fewer
natural disasters than poorer nations, richer nations do suffer less death from
disaster. Economic development provides implicit insurance against nature’s
shocks. Democracies and nations with higher-quality institutions suffer less
death from natural disaster (Khan).” Even economists who argue that natural
disasters can be beneficial to a country in the long term will concede that
this does not apply to countries that do not have the capital to aid in the
rebuild. This could be seen as evidence enough to the contrary; if natural
disasters are good for an economy why do they not help countries with a poor
economy? The answer appears to be because it requires a country to already be
wealthy before they can inflate their GDP when repairing after a natural
disaster.

Of course, the
size of the natural disaster that occurred is a factor as well. “In a
medium-term analysis (up to 5 years after the disaster event), comparing
counterfactual with observed gross domestic product, the authors find that
natural disasters on average can lead to negative consequences. Although the
negative effects may be small, they can become more pronounced depending mainly
on the size of the shock (Hockrainer)”.

The impact of
natural disasters on economic growth is a topic that is highly debated among
economists. While there is much agreeance that all natural disasters will
negatively effect the economies of communities in the short term, there is much
less agreeance when it comes to the effects natural disasters have long term.
The main argument that goes along with theorizing that natural disasters are
beneficial for the economy is the notable rise in GDP. However other economists
argue this stat is misleading and point to the effect natural disasters have on
developing countries as evidence that the GDP after a natural disaster is only
rising because the government can afford to funnel money back into rebuilding.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Keep reading