A Conundrum of Ethical Motivations: When Does Pursuing Well-being Become Selfish?

In the New York Times
article The Tale of The Corporate Spy
by Barry Meier, we are told the tale of Robert Moore, an extremely interesting
story with no shortage of ethical issues scattered within. Using the 7 Step
Velasquez Model of Decision Making we can use this tale as a case study for
complicated ethical issues and how to correct them.
First step to the 7 Steep Velasquez Model of Decision Making is
to gather the facts. Robert Moore was a failed movie director/producer. He was
in his 40’s, divorced and living back home with mom and dad when he was
contacted by K2 Intelligence. They paid him to work as a spy, he snuck into the
camps of anti-asbestos groups under the guise of a documentarian working to
make a like-minded documentary. His true intentions were far more dastardly;
still, the intentions of his employer were crueler that he could imagine. With
footage of the activists he would report back to K2. He would have insider
knowledge on their whereabouts, strategies, and weaknesses. On the flip-side
“He secretly tape-recorded activists, monitored their strategy sessions and,
presenting himself as a journalist, did work for the World Health Organization-
all while on the payroll of the firm’s asbestos industry client. (Meier, 2018)”
So in quick summary of the K2 Investigation from Moore’s
standing at least, we have a man who wanted to be a film-maker but failed. He
wanted a chance to come back. K2 offered him that. Albeit, through extremely unorthodox
means. Under the guise of a documentarian he filmed anti-asbestos activists
giving them false belief that he was making a film that would shed light on the
negatives of asbestos use. Meanwhile, this footage was being sent to K2 and
investigated by it’s researchers who were working to shut down or counter
anti-asbestos research and activism. K2 had it’s hands in a company that owned
asbestos mines on the border of Russia. The footage that Moore provided K2
helped them counter research with research of their own by staying ahead of
them. He also lead them to Thailand, where he identified as a battle-ground for
asbestos construction debate. It was around this time Moore claimed he finally
realized the magnitude, and negative effects of his actions. According to Moore
he was morally conflicted. One hand, he was helping a clearly harmful
organization. On the other hand, he was in a place that gave him the
opportunity to foil the plot instead of being replaced by someone who would
fulfill the promise and help the continued use of asbestos. The story of Robert
Moore is quite a conundrum.
The ethical dillemas here are two-fold. First of all, Moore’s
footage was directly helping K2 counter the rising activism against the use of
asbestos in developing and 3rd world country. K2’s goal is to have
the general public of a nation like Thailand ignorant to the obvious risks and
dangers of asbestos. It is an objective fact that the use of asbestos in
construction can be fatal. This was known by K2. Moore was, at the least,
indirectly help facilitate the continued use of it on the homes of innocent
humans. One could argue through the works of Socrates’ main philosophy “Ethical
Wisdom” that Moore’s actions were inherently unethical. “The recognition of the
fundamental importance of the ethical in the life of man (humankind) and of
doing good as the basic principle of human activity (Lecker, 44)”. By this
school of thought, Moore was passed unethical actions the first time he sent
footage back to K2.
The second ethical
dilemma was the information that emerged once the operation was blown up and K2
and Robert Moore were both exposed. It was quickly made known that Robert Moore
was getting paid 100K per year during his time as an undercover journalist.
Furthermore, journalist was only part of it. In reality, the report sounds as
if he acted more as a con-man. “On some cases, Mr. Moore, who had dabbled in
journalism before his comedy career, posed as a reporter. He also once
disguised himself as a deliveryman with a large floral bouquet to get into a
mansion owned by a Russian oligarch. Mr. Moore, who was eager to get back into
television, saw as possible fodder for documentaries (Meier, 2018)”. From this
angle, it appears that Moore had no intentions of changing any opinions at all
on asbestos. He may have been selfishly acting to further his own career with
total disregard for others, neither warm nor dastardly. According to Aristotle,
Moore would have no responsibility to take care of others unless he made it
part of his own habit of life. If he is by habit, selfish, and driven to get
back into the movie business, it may not be unethical by Aristotle’s school of
thought.
One alternative would
have been for Robert Moore to get full in on the operation and not propose the
idea to Global Witness of making a “double-agent” scenario. Besides, by not
disclosing his salary he was not fully committing to the action. According to
Aristotle “Further, all men are to be loved equally. But since you cannot do
good to all, you are to pay special regard to those who, by (accident)…are
brought into closer connections with you (Lecker, 61).” By this school of
thought, Moore was in no obligation to help anyone but himself and those he
came in close personal contact with. Had he kept this operation under better
wraps and worked himself a higher pay raise; or into the movie industry like he
wanted, he could have been self-sufficient and able to help random individuals
in his life.
A second alternative
would be to follow the school of thought by Socrates. Since it is essentially
an objective act that asbestos is harmful, and it’s use would be fatal to the
construction workers hired to install it, then being a part of this process
directly harms a fellow member of human-kind. By this logic it would be ethical
to contact Global Witness or a similar organization directly and come clean
about any of your knowledge and past actions as soon as realizing it was
unethical.
There are three main
stakeholders in this scenario. Robert Moore, K2, and countless humans (many in
developing nations) who unbeknownst to the entire situation. Robert Moore has a
six-figure salary and a possible path on his dream to gain. He has his entire
career, and legal ramifications to face if he loses. K2 has, on top of
countless legal ramifications, large profit loss (asbestos mines and supplies
becoming useless), global relations, and the future of a strong and rising
company on the line. Humans unfortunate to work with asbestos without even
being educated on the effects and diseases it can manifest have nothing to
gain. It is highly unlikely any “savings” made by K2 would be passed on to the
construction workers. While on the other hand, they have everything to lose.
Asbestos is an extremely dangerous construction material.
Considering the reckless
greed and absurdity needed to continue installing asbestos in new buildings
despite the consistent research agreeing with it’s harmful effects is
inherently unethical. For this reason it is clear that Socrates’ main
philosophy of “Ethical Wisdom” is more than applicable.
No matter how you slice
it, Robert Moore was acting unethical and selfish. He was fully aware of the
dangers of asbestos. Anyone lucky enough to receive a high-school education in
a developed country likely knows that. The 100K salary isn’t even the main
signifier of his greed. It is already established that Robert Moore knew full
and well that asbestos was harmful. If the rallies he attended didn’t sway him,
then his proposal to Global Witness is evidence he knew the whole time. Except
he wasn’t there to come clean, he was there to try and flip over to the morally
correct side without ditching his documentary. Although he was able to discern
what was ethically correct and what was ethically wrong (hurting humankind vs.
not hurting human kind), he was not able to put more importance on this ethical
dilemma than his dreams of breaking into the movie industry.
If the most ethical
alternative was chosen (Ethical Wisdom) tradeoffs for the stake holders would
be as follows.
Robert Moore would be at
the mercy of the law. He would be in their favor though being the original
whistle-blower. It is impossible to accurately predict what would have come of
Moore legally, but it is fair to assume he would not have faced jail-time given
his ulterior motive and the fact that he was left in the dark for much of the
operation.
K2 would face full blunt
of legal ramifications. They would end up having for their asbestos mines in
Russia, leading to an immense loss of profit. Contracts would fall through
globally. This would lead to strains on the companies relations across the
world as well as its own longevity.
The people who would be
constructing these asbestos based homes or living in them would be able to
avoid the inconvience of being around a material that will likely shorten their
lifespan by 30 plus years.
Following the 7 Step
Velasquez Model of Decision Making, and basing my decision on the facts at
hand, the stakeholders, and their possible tradeoffs, that action to take
appears obvious to me. Following the school of thought lead by Socrates,
“Ethical Wisdom” should have been used by anyone involved in this absolutely
immoral operation to know that selling a poisonous material to people who don’t
know it is poisonous is unethical. For the sake of all the victims lives that
would be trampled and shortened by the greed of Moore and K2, I would gladly
take the course of action of following Ethical Wisdom and blowing the whistle
on this operation. I would have no sympathy for K2 as they filled in their
mines, and I would have no feelings for Robert Moore as he went a different
path to pursue the movie business. The most important thing, is that the
greater good, being good to the greater human population, was what was catered
to.


