Do Muslims Have A Right To Force Dietary Restrictions On Non-Muslims?
Throughout history
states across the globe have run into both internal and external problems due
to differences in religion, as well as religion practice. Sometimes these
religion differences manifest in sects as small as communities and towns. It is
places like this where the Muslim neighborhoods clash with neighboring towns
who sacrifice livestock in ways they find unholy. The question becomes, who is
in the right? Philosophy may not have the answers, but it can certainly open
the door for discussion.
In the context of
this chapter this discussion question most closely relates to the philosophical
ideas of Protagoras, one of the most famous of all the Sophists. Born in
northern Greece, Protagoras was best known for his cultural relativist
viewpoint. It was not only his belief that values of individuals differ from
culture to culture, but his implication that values cannot be accepted as one
collective cultural background.
Following the
philosophy of Protagoras, I would suggest that the Government of India give
into the demands of the majority of their country and ban the slaughtering of
livestock in their “unholy matter” to appease the masses. Protagoras would have
believed this to be the most practical solution. As he believed cultures will
always have differences.
Now, although this
isn’t a philosophy that has been brought up in lecture yet. I disagree that
Protagoras’ belief on the matter is necessarily the most just. I believe that
Protagoras’s approach is a little too lenient towards the majority, rather than
a freedom for all members of society.



